The M52 engine and the Nikasil problem

John Avis by | February 2, 2013 | E46 E36

There is already a lot of information online about the problems with M52 and M60 engines due to the aluminium block and Nikasil cylinder bore lining used in most countries where these engines were sold.
There is already a lot of information online about the problems with M52 and M60 engines due to the aluminium block and Nikasil cylinder bore lining used in most countries where these engines were sold.

I have often heard that this problem doesn't apply in Australia but I have serious doubts whether that is true.

One person I spoke to had worked as a mechanic at a BMW dealer in Sydney for a long time and had first hand experience with problems with M52 engines when these first appeared in local 3 and 5 series models. He told me that they replaced many M52 engine blocks under warranty, and some cars needed multiple replacement blocks. This came up as a result of me saying that I was looking to buy an E36 or E46 323i at the time, and his advice was to stay well clear as even models with the replacement block could not be trusted.

What I don't know is whether the replacement blocks provided by BMW Australia were just the same Nikasil lined blocks or something different like Alusil lined or cast iron blocks.

Quite a few years later when I had an E36 323i, which had been in an accident and which I had bought for parts, I spoke to a mechanic who worked for an independant BMW and European car specialist workshop and was well aware of problems with the M52 engine. He believed that the problem with these engines could be due to bore glazing, and that a lot of BMW owner's don't drive their cars the way they were intended. I know most of the BMW owner's manuals I have read have said that you should run the engine over 4,000rpm regularly to keep the engine in good shape.

The M52-powered 323i I owned briefly did blow a lot of blue smoke, which means that it was burning oil, but unfortunately I never found out the cause. In addition to the problems I mentioned, there are other common causes for oil consumption on these engines that are a lot less serious and less expensive to fix.

Would I buy an M52 powered BMW? I would probably avoid it unless it was a car I really wanted, and then a pre-purchase compression test would probably be money well spent.

Update: I understand that models after 1999 had blocks fitted with iron liners (possibly as part of the M52TU update). I believe these are better but still have some issues. Further research is required.

BMW M52 engine block

Related Posts


1998/1999 BMW 318is Sport (Australia)

by John Avis | March 22, 2017

In 1998, near the end of the E36 life, BMW Australia introduced a limited edition version of the 318is called the "Sport".

E36 Technical Tips

BMW E36 window stuck in open position

by John Avis | December 21, 2016

My passenger side window on my 1998 318is coupe has been stuck in the closed position for some time. I can usually get it going by removing the door trim and then hitting the window motor with a mallet. As it is summer and hot and my air conditioning also stopped working some time ago, I thought I would try and get the window working.

E36 Technical Tips

How to fix BMW E36 squeaking and grinding steering wheel

by John Avis | June 17, 2016

If you hear a squeaking noise coming from behind your 1991 to 1998 BMW 3 series steering wheel, or possibly the steering doesn't feel so smooth and maybe binds every now and then, then there's something you can do fairly easily to try and fix it.


There are no comments yet. Be the first to leave a comment!

Leave a Comment
E30 E36 E46 General Magazine Articles My 1990 318is My 1991 325i My 1994 318is My 1995 M3 My 1997 318is My 1998 318is My second 1990 318is Technical Tips

About me

I am a bit of a 3 series fanatic, having owned a couple of E30s and a few E36s, plus a few parts cars. I like the combination of the compact size, good performance and handling, and that they are more sports sedan than an impractical and extrovert sports car. This blog is a place to share my experience and knowledge.


Get the latest posts delivered to your inbox.